FF News — The Fintech News Network

EXCLUSIVE: "Banking on the Lloyd Review?" - Ron Delenvo, The Payment Choice Alliance in 'The Paytech Magazine'

By Lauren Towner · 16 November 2026

Press Release: EXCLUSIVE: "Banking on the Lloyd Review?" - Ron Delenvo, The Payment Choice Alliance in 'The Paytech Magazine' | Featured Image by FF News

Ron Delnevo, Chair of the UK’s Payment Choice Alliance, is sceptical that this latest review of branch closures will satisfy customers.

The Financial Services and Markets Bill 2026 was introduced in the House of Lords on 19 May 2026. Paragraph 3 of the Bill was of particular interest to those concerned about the diminution of access to banking services created by the closure of, on average, around a dozen bank branches every week since January 2015. That’s well over 7,000 branches, along with the ATMs that were located in them. Here is the relevant paragraph, in Part 1 of the Bill:

3. Access to banking services (1)

The Treasury may by regulations make such provision as they consider appropriate in connection with providing access to banking services.

(2) In making regulations, the Treasury must have regard to any recommendations of the independent review into in-person banking access, announced by the Economic Secretary to the Treasury in a statement to the House of Commons on 14 May 2026.

There were a few more sub paragraphs to complete Paragraph 3 of the Bill, but the whole Paragraph took up less than half a page of a document that ran to 138 pages. Not much for an issue of such importance to so many members of the British public.

In any event, the Chair appointed by HM Treasury to lead the independent review of access to banking services was Richard Lloyd OBE. Lloyd has an interesting CV, which includes, in addition to his current role as Chair of the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority, serving as Executive Director of Which? and Head of Policy at Shelter.

So we should have high hopes of Lloyd, given that he clearly has a keen interest in consumers in general and the neediest in particular.

Of course, HM Treasury has a history of severely limiting the scope of the independent reviews it sponsors.

Notoriously, in July 2023, Joe Garner, ex-CEO of Nationwide Building Society, was asked by then Chancellor Jeremy Hunt to Chair a Future of Payments Review – the only problem being that Garner was told that cash was ‘out of scope’ of his work. I spoke to Garner and told him he should have refused to carry out the Review on that basis – especially, as Garner was forced to admit, 30 per cent of submissions he had received included references to cash, but they couldn’t be included because of the limitation on scope imposed by the Treasury.

Sadly, despite the colour of ties and scarves worn by Government ministers having changed since 2023, the desire of HM Treasury officials to limit the scope of Reviews has not. Here’s what Lloyd had to say about the scope of his Review in his first statement as Chair.

“There may be several different types of groups, including those who are vulnerable or have specific needs, that rely on access to in-person banking services. There are also those who desire or prefer to have access to in-person banking; however, this Review is focussed on those who require access.”

The Review’s scope creates a clear hierarchy of need: it isolates those who ‘require’ access – individuals who face total exclusion if a physical branch closes – from those who ‘rely’ on access, including vulnerable people who could be pushed into digital environments they neither want nor can safely navigate.

And it completely ignores those who ‘desire or prefer’ in-person banking. Elsewhere, Lloyd has made reference to the focus being on those to whom access is ‘essential’.

On reading about this proposed scope limitation, I immediately contacted Lloyd, sending him the findings of YouGov market research carried out in May 2026, the same month he was appointed to chair the Review.

That research demonstrates quite vividly what the British public ‘desire’.

To the question ‘How important, if at all, do you think it is to have access to a physical bank branch in your local area?’, 76 per cent of the adults responding confirmed that it was either very or fairly important to them to have local access to a physical bank branch.

To the question ‘Thinking of the future of banking and the ways to bank, which of the following best reflects your view?’ , 53 per cent of adults responded that it should be equally possible to use a physical bank branch and online banking for everything, with 36 per cent believing some online transactions should be capable of also being carried out at a physical bank branch.

The YouGov research findings are broadly in line with research carried out in 2026 on behalf of the UK Post Office. This research found that 68 per cent of the public want face-to-face banking services close to home and 48 per cent use in-person banking at least once a month.

So Lloyd is well aware of what the British public want – or ‘desire’ to use his own word.

The question is, can he bring himself to ignore that and stick to the narrow focus the Treasury favours, on the surely relatively small number of people and organisations for whom access to in-person banking services is absolutely essential.

I hope that Lloyd finds the courage to recommend that the British public gets what they desire. One thing is certain: the Labour Government is well aware of what the public actually want.

On 4 December 2023, I had a call with Tulip Siddiq, the Labour MP who in 2024 became Economic Secretary to the Treasury. I told her that the 350 Banking Hubs promised by 2029 to deliver community in-person banking services was a totally inadequate number.

Instead, at least 1,200 are required, so that every UK community with 5,000 or more residents that has ever had a bank branch can automatically be given a Banking Hub. I was assured by Ms Siddiq and her colleague on the call that many more than 350 Banking Hubs would be provided.

Nearly three years on, with the new Labour Government at the helm of the country for the last two years, the 350 promise, made by Cash Access UK (funded and owned by Barclays, HSBC, Lloyds Banking Group and NatWest) remains unchanged.

One thing that Lloyd can take courage from is that a new Prime Minister is now in Downing Street. Andy Burnham seems ready to take strong decisions to give the British public what they want. It is clear from the research results that guaranteeing in-person local banking services would be hugely popular with the British public – aka voters.

In our 20-page submission to the Richard Lloyd Review, the Payment Choice Alliance made the following recommendations in relation to access to banking services, including cash:

■ A new independent Cash and Community Banking Services Regulator is needed.

■ Changes to UK banking services have for many years been made to suit UK banks, with insufficient regard for the public interest. To rebalance this, funding for community banking services, including cash, should be provided via a levy on bank profits, with the new Regulator responsible for setting the level of the levy.

■ A minimum of 1,200 Full-Service Banking Hubs are required, so that every UK community with 5,000 or more residents that has previously enjoyed access to bank branch services can automatically have such a Hub. All Hubs should operate six days per week and provide a full range of advice services, along with 24/7 cash access. Other communities can apply to the new Regulator for a Hub.

■ The Cash and Community Banking Services Regulator should be tasked with giving consideration to facilitating new potential providers of access to community banking services, including branch services at community level.

Lloyd is due to submit the results of his Review by the middle of this month (October 2026). MPs will only have been back from their summer holidays a few days and are also trying to find space to debate the new Financial Services and Markets Bill. We wouldn’t want the wishes of the British public in regard to access to in-person banking services to get overlooked.

So, the Payment Choice Alliance recommendations were all sent in good time...directly to Number 10 Downing Street.

More Payments news →

More from Thought Leadership