i2c Research Reveals 42% of U.S. Consumers 'Self-Deny' Credit Due to Misperceived Approval Odds
By Effie Foxtrot · 8 September 2025
In brief: i2c research reveals 42% of U.S. consumers 'self-deny' credit products due to a false fear of denial, creating a major opportunity for issuers to win customers through transparency and flexible card features.
| Perceived Denial Rate | 42% |
|---|---|
| Study Sample Size | 2,000 U.S. consumers |
| Premium Feature Fee | $99 average one-time fee |
| Planned Purchase Usage | 53% of consumers |

A significant perception gap in the U.S. credit market is causing eligible consumers to "self-deny" credit applications based on a false expectation of rejection. New research indicates that while 42% of consumers doubt their approval chances, actual denial rates are nearly three times lower, presenting a major strategic opening for fintechs to improve financial literacy and product flexibility.
What was announced
The study, titled "Consumer Credit Economy: Strategy vs. Spontaneity- Navigating the Great Credit Divide," was conducted by i2c Inc. in collaboration with PYMNTS Intelligence. Based on a survey of over 2,000 U.S. consumers, the report highlights a disconnect between consumer perception and the reality of credit accessibility. While many consumers believe they would be rejected for new credit products, the data suggests that a large portion of the population is opting out of the financial system unnecessarily.
The research identifies that credit serves a dual purpose for modern users: 53% of consumers use it for planned, strategic purchases, while others rely on it as a reactive safety net for unexpected expenses. This demand for versatility is particularly high among younger demographics and those with tighter budgets. Notably, 59% of consumers expressed a desire for credit cards that allow them to switch between earning rewards and receiving a lower interest rate on a monthly basis. Furthermore, the study found a willingness to pay for this level of control, with respondents indicating they would pay an average one-time fee of $99 for cards offering enhanced benefits and flexibility.
Credit building also remains a primary motivator for market entry. Approximately 26% of consumers who do not currently hold a credit card cited the desire to improve their credit score as their main reason for considering an application. This focus on financial progress is especially prevalent among younger individuals and those currently holding prime or subprime scores.
"It's no longer enough for banks to simply approve or deny applications; they must first address the psychological barriers that cause many eligible consumers to self-select out of the application process due to anticipated denial."
David Durovy, SVP of Transformation at i2c Inc.
The companies involved
i2c Inc. is a global provider of banking, credit, and payment solutions. Operating on a single global platform, the company enables financial institutions and fintechs to launch and manage high-scale credit, debit, and prepaid programs. The firm recently marked its 25th year in operation, positioning itself as a long-standing infrastructure provider in the payments space. Its technology is designed to move beyond "one-size-fits-all" financial products, offering hyper-targeted messaging and real-time communication tools to help issuers engage with their customer base more effectively.
PYMNTS Intelligence is a research and data analysis firm focused on the payments and broader fintech industry. It provides deep-dive reports and indices that track consumer behavior, merchant trends, and the evolution of the digital economy. By partnering with infrastructure providers like i2c, the organization produces data-driven insights into how financial products are utilized across different demographic segments in the United States and globally.
What FF News has reported before
FF News has extensively tracked i2c’s growth and leadership changes over the past several years. In mid-2026, the company announced a significant expansion of its executive team, including the appointment of a new CFO and Chief Client Officer to support its global scaling efforts. This followed the recognition of i2c CEO Amir Wain as Fintech Leader of the Year by Juniper Research.
The company’s international footprint has also been a point of focus, particularly its role in enabling digital transformation for traditional banks. This was evidenced by the Belize Bank partnership, which utilized i2c’s platform to modernize its banking services. Additionally, the firm celebrated its 25th anniversary in late 2025, highlighting its history of innovation in the payments and banking-as-a-service sectors.
What this means
The revelation that 42% of consumers are "self-denying" suggests that the credit industry is facing a communication crisis rather than a liquidity one. For years, issuers have focused on the mechanics of approval, but these findings indicate that the marketing of credit has failed to reach those who need it most. If consumers are willing to pay a $99 fee for flexibility, it signals a shift in value perception: users no longer want static rewards; they want dynamic tools that adapt to their monthly financial health. This puts significant pressure on legacy banks with rigid tech stacks to modernize or risk losing the next generation of credit-conscious consumers to more agile fintech competitors.
Frequently asked questions
Why are U.S. consumers avoiding credit card applications?
According to i2c research, 42% of consumers believe they would be denied a new credit card, a figure nearly three times the actual industry denial rate. This 'perception gap' leads many eligible individuals to 'self-deny' by never applying, despite their actual creditworthiness.
What features do consumers want in modern credit cards?
Consumers are increasingly seeking flexibility. The study found that 59% of consumers want a card that allows them to choose monthly between earning rewards or receiving a lower interest rate. Additionally, consumers are willing to pay an average one-time fee of $99 for cards with enhanced benefits.
How can banks improve credit card approval confidence?
Banks can bridge the approval perception gap by implementing transparent marketing and financial literacy programs. By using i2c’s hyper-targeted messaging, issuers can provide clear narratives on how their products help consumers strategically build credit for long-term financial success.
About the companies
PYMNTS Intelligence
6 stories on FF News since 2025
Previously on FF News:
- Riskified and Marqeta Partner to Boost Card Authorization Rates and Slash False Declines 5 August 2026
- Middle-Market Growth Stalled by Outdated Financial Infrastructure, i2c Research Reveals 9 April 2026
- i2c Report Reveals 83% of SMBs Confident in Credit Approval as Demand for Flexible Features Surges 12 November 2025
Companies in this story: i2c, PYMNTS Intelligence
People in this story: David Durovy, Karen Webster