Only 13% of Consumers Trust AI to Handle Financial Charge Disputes Alone, Five9 Research Reveals
By Effie Foxtrot · 17 November 2026
In brief: Research from Five9 shows that only 13% of UK consumers want AI to independently handle charge disputes, while 91% insist on human involvement for high-stakes banking escalations.
| AI Dispute Acceptance | 13% of UK consumers |
|---|---|
| Human Dispute Preference | 51% of UK consumers |
| Escalation Human Need | 91% of UK consumers |
| UK FS Firm AI Adoption | 86% (BoE / FCA survey) |

New research reveals a significant trust gap in financial services automation, as only 13% of UK consumers believe AI should handle charge disputes independently. While 86% of financial firms have adopted AI, customers remain resistant to fully automated resolutions for high-stakes issues like refunds and identity verification, demanding human oversight for sensitive transactions.
What was announced
Analysis of research conducted by Five9 indicates a stark divide between the rapid adoption of artificial intelligence by financial institutions and the comfort levels of their customers. While a joint survey from the Bank of England and the Financial Conduct Authority suggests that 86% of financial services firms are already utilizing AI, consumers are expressing significant reservations regarding its use in high-stakes scenarios. Specifically, only 13% of UK consumers who recently interacted with financial providers believe that AI should be permitted to handle charge disputes without any human involvement.
The data, derived from the 2026 Consumer CX Report, shows that 51% of respondents want charge disputes handled entirely by a person, while 37% would accept AI involvement only if there is direct human oversight or approval. This preference for human intervention extends across several sensitive areas: 91% of respondents believe high-stakes escalations require a human touch, 86% want human involvement in refunds or financial adjustments, and 85% feel the same about identity verification.
Despite these concerns, the research suggests that consumers see value in AI for lower-stakes interactions. More than three-quarters of those surveyed believe AI can play a role in account status enquiries, and 52% of those who have recently contacted a financial provider view AI as a useful tool for general customer service. The findings are based on a study of 1,000 UK respondents, with a specific focus on 413 individuals who had engaged with financial services customer support in the six months prior to the April 2026 survey period.
"The question for banks isn't whether AI belongs in customer service, but where it should be allowed to act alone. Customers may be comfortable with AI answering a straightforward account enquiry, but a disputed charge or sensitive financial issue demands a different level of care."
Andy Dignan, President at Five9
The companies involved
Five9 is a prominent provider of cloud-based contact center software, operating in the Contact Center as a Service (CCaaS) market. The company focuses on providing the infrastructure that allows businesses, including those in the highly regulated financial services sector, to manage customer interactions across multiple channels such as voice, email, and chat. Headquartered in the United States, the company maintains a significant global footprint to support international markets, including the United Kingdom, where it assists firms in navigating the transition from legacy on-premises hardware to cloud-native solutions.
The company’s platform is designed to integrate artificial intelligence into the customer service workflow, offering tools for both automated self-service and agent assistance. In the broader fintech landscape, Five9 positions itself as a facilitator of digital transformation, helping banks and insurers balance the cost-saving potential of automation with the qualitative needs of customer experience. As financial institutions face increasing pressure to modernize their tech stacks while adhering to strict compliance and consumer protection standards, Five9’s role involves providing the analytical and operational tools necessary to measure and manage these complex interactions. The firm’s research initiatives, such as the Consumer CX Report, serve to provide the industry with benchmarks for consumer sentiment in an increasingly automated environment.
What this means
The findings signal a critical juncture for the fintech sector, where the drive for operational efficiency through AI is clashing with the fundamental need for consumer trust. While straightforward requests are being successfully offloaded to automated systems, the data suggests that financial institutions cannot yet rely on AI to manage "moments of truth"—those high-friction interactions where a customer’s financial security feels at risk. The industry is entering a phase where the quality of human-AI collaboration will be a greater differentiator than the sheer volume of automation. Firms that fail to maintain visible human accountability in dispute resolution risk alienating their most valuable customers.
Frequently asked questions
Do UK consumers trust AI to resolve credit card charge disputes?
No. According to Five9's research, only 13% of surveyed UK consumers believe AI should handle charge disputes independently, whereas 51% prefer charge disputes to be handled entirely by a human agent.
How many financial firms are currently using AI in customer service?
A joint Bank of England and Financial Conduct Authority survey revealed that 86% of responding financial services institutions are currently utilizing artificial intelligence technology.
What customer service queries are consumers comfortable letting AI handle?
Consumers are most comfortable using AI for straightforward tasks. More than three-quarters (77%) believe AI can assist with order or account status enquiries, with 35% comfortable letting AI handle them completely independently.
About the companies
Five9
Website · 1 story on FF News since 2026
Companies in this story: Five9
People in this story: Andy Dignan