FF News — The Fintech News Network

Fintech Insider 128: News - Are You Bad When You're Big?

By FF Newsroom · 21 August 2016

Fintech Insider 128: News - Are You Bad When You're Big?

A panel of industry experts, including FF News’ own Ali Paterson, has convened to tackle the intersection of social responsibility and digital payments. The discussion highlights the growing tension between platform neutrality and ethical oversight as major players like PayPal and WhatsApp navigate complex regulatory and social landscapes in the global fintech market.

What was announced

The latest episode of the fintech-focused broadcast features a comprehensive review of current market shifts, led by hosts David, Jason, and Simon. Joining the panel are Liz Lumley, a global fintech commentator and Girl, Disrupted; Ali Paterson, Editor-in-Chief of Fintech Finance; and Charlie Wood, Principal Consultant at Capco. A primary focus of the discussion is the introduction of payment features to WhatsApp and the implications for the messaging giant's entry into the financial services space.

The panel also addresses the persistent gap in customer service quality between smaller institutions and major banks. With First Direct consistently topping service polls while larger incumbents lag behind, the group explores whether a bank's size inherently correlates with a decline in user experience. The conversation questions if being "bad" naturally follows being "big" in the eyes of the consumer.

Ethical considerations take center stage regarding PayPal’s role in managing donations to controversial groups, specifically the KKK. The segment examines the difficult balance between maintaining a neutral platform for free speech and exercising social responsibility. Additionally, the episode covers the rise of "pocket money" startups, the impact of retraining versus job cuts in the financial sector, and a circular economy initiative in Amsterdam that converts waste into digital tokens. The broadcast concludes with an interview with James Lloyd, Asia-Pacific Fintech Leader at EY, focusing on recent developments in the Chinese fintech sector and Alipay.

The companies involved

Capco is represented in the discussion by Charlie Wood, who serves as a Principal Consultant for the firm. The organization operates within the financial consulting space, providing strategic advice to the sector. EY is a professional services firm with a global reach, represented by James Lloyd, the company’s Asia-Pacific Fintech Leader. His role focuses on the rapidly evolving digital finance landscape in the Asian markets, including the growth of platforms like Alipay.

The discussion also features insights from Fintech Finance, a media organization covering the global financial technology sector, represented by its Editor-in-Chief, Ali Paterson. Major technology and financial brands mentioned include WhatsApp, which is expanding into the payments space, and PayPal, a global digital payments service. First Direct is highlighted for its specific market position as a leader in customer service, contrasting with the performance of larger banking institutions. These companies represent a cross-section of the industry, from established financial services and consultancies to digital-first payment platforms and media commentators.

What this means

The industry is reaching a point where the neutrality of payment rails is being fundamentally questioned. As PayPal and WhatsApp navigate the complexities of social responsibility and censorship, the fintech sector must decide if it is a neutral utility or an active participant in social governance. This shift suggests that future market leaders will be defined not just by their transaction speeds, but by their ethical frameworks. Meanwhile, the struggle of large-scale banks to match the customer service levels of smaller competitors like First Direct indicates that digital transformation has yet to solve the human element of banking. Incumbents are under pressure to prove that scale does not necessitate a decline in user experience.

More from News