Younger Shoppers Are Reshaping Dispute Behaviour, Raising Stakes for Merchants

The Chargebacks911 Cardholder Dispute Index 2025 reveals a fundamental shift in how younger, mobile-native consumers handle payment disputes. This digital-first chargeback behaviour sets a new benchmark for convenience, speed, and app-driven support.

The 2025 Cardholder Dispute Index, based on responses from over 1,200 cardholders in the U.S. and U.K., shows that consumers aged 18–44 are driving a generational shift in dispute behaviour, one that is shaped by mobile-first habits, digital payment tools, and expectations for instant resolution.

“Younger shoppers are digital natives who want what they want, when they want it. When it comes to disputing a transaction with a merchant, they aren’t waiting on hold, searching for support emails, or even looking to speak to an actual person,” said Monica Eaton, CEO of Chargebacks911. “More often than not, they’ll tap an app, file a dispute with their bank, get an instant refund and move on. They do this because it’s convenient and it works nearly every time. If merchants aren’t meeting them with digital-first solutions, they’re already behind.”

Generational Disruption Key Findings:

• Mobile wallet preference skews young: Consumers under 30 are more than twice as likely to prefer mobile wallets than those over 60.
• Buy Now, Pay Later adoption is rising: Nearly half of shoppers aged 18–44 have used BNPL services, compared to just 33% of those over 60.
• Bank-first mentality: 83% of 18–44-year-olds prefer resolving disputes through their bank, not the merchant. Just one-third of consumers over 60 disputed a transaction without contacting the merchant in the past year.
• Dispute short-cuts are normalized: Over half of younger consumers skip contacting the seller altogether and initiate disputes directly through mobile banking platforms.

These behaviours reveal more than young consumers’ preference for convenience; it points to an evolution in consumer expectations. Shoppers today demand fast, seamless, app-driven service, and they reward brands that deliver with loyalty or punish those that don’t with disputes and defection.

The 2025 Cardholder Dispute Index warns that failing to meet digital-first standards puts merchants at risk of:

• Increased chargeback volume and revenue loss
• Damaged brand trust among high-value demographics
• Long-term loyalty erosion from a generation that expects more

“This isn’t just about better fraud protection—it’s about adapting to the modern customer experience,” Eaton added. “Brands must shift from reactive dispute management to proactive, frictionless support if they want to survive this generational shift.”

Eaton says to stay competitive, merchants must invest in digital dispute prevention—including transparent billing, accurate billing descriptors, streamlined refund flows, and always-available customer support—before the bank becomes the first point of contact.

According to the Chargebacks911 Cardholder Dispute Index, merchants must now prioritize digital-first service orrisk losing the loyalty of a generation that demands immediate assistance. To access the full 2025 Cardholder Dispute Index, visit https://chargebacks911.com/cardholder-dispute-index.